Designing Indie Board Games: Part 1
Learn how to start developing an original tabletop game using Tabletop Simulator in guest writer Dr. Gamenstein’s Indie Game Lab 1: Game Design Series!
Part 1 in a new series on game design
So You Wanna Be A Game Designer?
Out of all the players who use Tabletop Simulator, only a very small percentage of them have harnessed its ability to design and recreate games via the Steam Workshop. In an effort to increase that percentage, and the amount of independently designed original games on Tabletop Simulator in general, this new blog series will focus on the indie game designer. Starting with originating game concepts and alpha prototypes, running through beta play testing, and finally releasing via steam workshop, Indie Game Lab is for anyone who ever wanted to design their own game or get a game they loved into the virtual world.
Along the way, this series will explain and illustrate the best board game design tools built into Tabletop Simulator. We will also look at some 3rd party workshop mods and tools that will make the implementation of the game into TTS much simpler. You won’t need any skills other than the basic MS Paint program that comes with windows (although it would be great if you had knowledge of a better tool) If you already have Adobe/Blender or similar tool skills, you are fully prepared to make some awesome looking games in TTS.
Since you don’t need exceptional skills or experience to start your career as a fledgling game designer, we can get right to work. The first thing needed is inspiration, use your imagination, memories, or do a bit of research to get the creative juices flowing.
Game Conception
If you are interested in game design, then you most likely have some game experience to draw from. Yes, it may be from a player perspective, but all game designers come from that perspective. No one ever designed a game before playing one.
The great game designers are the ones who used their love and knowledge of games they played, to twist and mix many concepts and mechanics into a new concept. New, original game mechanics are actually quite rare. Most times a great game designer simply chooses the best mechanics for the game theme/category.
It is rare that a new game is released with game mechanics never seen before, but it is quite exciting when it happens and it works. So, if you have an idea for an original game mechanic, by all means test it out. But the point is that it is not necessary in order to design a great game. There are already 100 game mechanics that can be used, blended, mixed, and modified to make a completely original new game. It is more a matter of which mechanics to choose. So what is the best way to approach game conception from a designer’s point of view?
In order to answer that we first have to discuss the Chicken & The Egg argument in game design. Namely which comes first: Theme/Category or Mechanic? Since you will most likely refer to Boardgamegeek.com during your research, let’s use their definitions of Category*
*I tend to refer to BGG Category as the game Theme. I would consider the Game Category to be equivalent to Genre. So board game/card game/dice game etc is the Category/Genre and Theme would be sci-fi/pirates/economics. BGG basically combines both Category/Genre/Theme all into one list called CATEGORIES which is how it will be used in the blog series.
Most designers start with the Category and then choose mechanics that they enjoy, that will fit the theme, and that will influence the amount of luck/strategy in the game. The other option is to start with game mechanics and then decide on a theme once the gameplay is proven to be fun.
I tend to favor the later method for two reasons:
The Category doesn’t matter if the gameplay isn’t fun.
A good game could have a dozen viable categories.
Things to Watch out For
The issue many first-time game designers have is being married to the category at the expense of gameplay. A good exploration/trading game could be based on space traders, tractor-trailers, pirates, camels, etc… If you concentrate on designing a fun exploration trading game, players will accept it under a variety of categories.
A common pitfall for this happens when a designer gets stuck trying to find a mechanic or rule that explains something the player has to do, build or buy in, for example, the space trading game they are married to.
In this example, trying to get the concept of momentum and gravity into a space trading game to account for black holes and planetary gravity when moving ships is perceived as a “necessary” mechanic. Besides being difficult, it can also be boring to a player. In the world of this game, a spaceship has a pilot that should know about these things before you order them to move. Who wants a pilot who every time they get to point B says, “Oh wait I forgot to take into account our momentum and gravitational pull again…”
The simple solution is to take out these conflicting “mechanics” or change the theme to trucks or ships on a sea where the lack of the gravitational pull model makes no difference. You can still install a mechanic that has random whirlpools or evil Kraken for ships, or sinkholes, traffic jams, or mechanical issues for trucks without the need of complex, and from a gameplay standpoint, boring physics algorithm.
Getting Inspired
Finding the game concept and choosing mechanics is often the case of simply using your experience, imagination, and doing a little research on the great games of the past. Here are 3 ways to get inspired:
Recall games that you enjoyed. Particularly games that had great player interaction and replayability. What kind of mechanics were in those games? As you recall these games immediately think about whether the game could have easily been designed in another category.
For example, an easy trick is to take an old pirate game and turn it into a space trader game. Many of the economic, trade, and combat mechanics are going to transfer and can be modified to reflect the new category/theme of the game. But buying ships, cargo, weapons, movement, combats, etc...is going to have to be handled in some way so why not take inspiration from a good game people liked to play.
Use Boadgamegeek.com as a reference tool. The advanced search will allow you to sort games by dozens of parameters. Want to look up pirate games from the 80s? You can. Want to look up all the games in the last 20 years that used the worker placement mechanic? You can.
There are literally thousands of great, nearly forgotten games that the resourceful game designer could research and find mechanics and concepts which would be the basis for a completely new game. Upcycling old game mechanics, rules, and concepts is one of the best ways to start designing new games.Talk to other indie game designers. To make this easy, we have a Discord Server & Youtube channel made for indie game designers, playtesters, and board game fans who wish to support independent board game design.
Copying Is The Sincerest Form Of Laziness
Imitation is one thing, but flat out copying rules and mechanics verbatim is not game design. While every game designer borrows from a game or designer before them, there should always be an obvious distinction on how the new game twisted, modified, or re-interpreted the rules/mechanics it borrowed from. This is so easy to do that there is really no good excuse to copy other than sheer laziness.
A Look Ahead
While you spend some time checking out the Boardgamegeek resources below to get the initial game concept, Indie Game Lab will be working on the next post in the series: The Game Plan. In that post we will look at all the things that will go into making an indie board game and when you should have certain assets in development and/or completed.
Until then, good luck with your initial research and game concept. See you next time!
Helpful Board Game Geek Resources: Game Mechanics, Game Categories, Advanced Search
Meet Guest Writer Dr. Gamenstein!
Dr. Gamenstein is an indie game designer. He enjoys remote castles, lightning storms, artificial intelligence, and impressive door knockers. He is also a game designer for Bombard Games.
You can also join him on the Indie Game Labs Discord Server & Youtube Channel.
Connect With Indie Game Lab: Indie Game Lab Discord, Indie Game Lab Youtube
Are you thinking about designing a board game yourself? Ask your design questions in the comments below!
